Local expertise provided by Pitt Property Group, with Bimini led by Sheldon Pitt, Broker and Principal.

Bimini Bay Condos and Homes

Bimini Bay's condo and marina-view homes for sale typically average around $348,000, with recent listings spanning roughly $230,000 to $599,000 depending on size and view — a mix of condos and apartment-style units suited to both personal use and rental income. Beyond that tier, the community also includes larger luxury estate homes and villas reaching well into the millions, some with private docks, nearby beaches, and expansive water frontage. That's a wider spread than Bimini Cove's more uniform condo pricing, reflecting where Bimini Bay real estate sits within the broader Bimini real estate market.

Marina Access and Boat Slips

Bimini Bay's marina is central to the community, and ownership here often comes paired with direct marina access. Those focused specifically on dockage rather than a home or condo should see Bimini boat and dock slips for sale for current slip inventory at Bimini Bay's Mega Marina.

Bimini Bay Location

Bimini Bay's location on the northern side of the island puts it within easy reach of the rest of Bimini and the wider Bahamas — close enough to Alice Town for day-to-day errands, and a short trip to South Bimini's quieter communities when you want a change of pace. For those comparing island living across the wider Bahamas, Bimini's location 50 miles from Florida remains one of the shortest crossings of any Bahamian island, a big part of why sale activity here stays consistent even in slower seasons for other islands.

Bimini Bay Lifestyle

Bimini Bay sits close to Alice Town and the amenities of North Bimini, offering more resort-style infrastructure than the quieter communities across the rest of the island. It suits buyers drawn to world class fishing, boating, and a more active marina lifestyle than the private, low-density feel of Port Royal or the simpler condo living at Bimini Cove. As with the rest of the Bahamas, island living here means a slower pace overall, but Bimini Bay's marina and resort amenities keep it one of the more active corners of the Bimini islands.

Investing in Bimini Bay

Bimini Bay's mix of price points makes it accessible to a wide range of owners, from a condo purchase to a larger luxury estate investment. Purchases at $1,000,000 or more qualify for Bahamas Permanent Residency, which carries full tax neutrality, including exemption from capital gains — most relevant to buyers considering the community's higher-end homes and land. Like the rest of the Bahamas, there's no income or capital gains tax on property held here, a real advantage for anyone comparing a Bimini Bay purchase against real estate back in the U.S.

Compare Bimini Bay against Bimini Cove real estate, Port Royal real estate, and the broader South Bimini real estate market, or see the island-wide picture at Bimini real estate. Buyers weighing a build rather than a finished home can browse vacant land across Bimini.

Before You Buy in Bimini Bay

As with any Bahamas purchase, a title search, survey, and local attorney are standard steps regardless of price point. Given the marine environment, factor in ongoing maintenance for waterfront and marina-adjacent units, and confirm current property tax and foreign-investment registration requirements with a Bahamian attorney or accountant, since these vary by property type and use.

Why Work With Pitt Property Group

Pitt Property Group is a boutique, Bahamian-owned brokerage. Bimini is led directly by Sheldon Pitt, Broker and Principal, a Bimini native with over 30 years of experience across the Bimini islands and recognition from Caribbean Journal as a leading expert on the market — direct, local knowledge of Bimini Bay, Bimini Cove, Port Royal, and South Bimini alike, not a generalist's read on the Bahamas real estate market.

Frequently Asked Questions

How much do condos cost in Bimini Bay?

Condos and marina-view listings typically average around $348,000, with recent activity ranging from roughly $230,000 to $599,000. Larger luxury estate homes and land run well beyond that range — search current listings above for what's active now.

How far is Bimini Bay from Miami?

Like the rest of the Bimini islands, Bimini Bay's location sits roughly 50 miles from Miami, Florida — one of the shortest crossings from the U.S. to the Bahamas.

What makes Bimini Bay different from Bimini Cove or Port Royal?

Bimini Bay offers a more active, marina-centered lifestyle with resort-style infrastructure near North Bimini's town center. Bimini Cove offers simpler, lower-maintenance condo living, while Port Royal offers land and single-family homes with more privacy and space.

Can foreigners buy property in Bimini Bay?

Yes. Most residential purchases, including by American buyers, are open to foreign buyers, who register through the Bahamas Investment Authority.

Is Bimini Bay a good investment?

Its mix of price points from everyday condos to luxury estate homes for sale, supports both personal use and rental potential, though buyers should confirm current association fees, maintenance costs, and registration requirements before purchasing.

Speak with a Bimini specialist