Eleuthera Homes For Rent | Harbour Island, Spanish Wells and Governors Harbour Long Term Rentals
Eleuthera homes for rent range from entry apartments in James Cistern from approximately $1,800 per month to premium rental properties at Harbour Island reaching $9,000 per month. The Eleuthera rental market serves long-term residents, seasonal lifestyle renters, expats, and buyers exploring the island before purchasing. The island-wide median is approximately $3,500 per month. Sheldon Pitt at Pitt Property Group is the specialist for Eleuthera and Out Island real estate. Contact Sheldon at (242) 544-7509 or sheldon@pittpropertygroup.com. Browse the full Bahamas homes for rent hub and Nassau long-term rentals for comparisons.
Eleuthera Rental Areas
Harbour Island Rentals
Harbour Island is Eleuthera's most sought-after rental address — the pink sand beach destination with a village character and luxury lifestyle that has attracted international residents for decades. Turning Tides at Harbour Island is available at approximately $9,000 per month — one of the highest rental price points on Eleuthera. Harbour Island rentals command a significant premium over mainland Eleuthera properties reflecting the island's exclusivity and limited supply. Browse Harbour Island real estate for sale for purchase options.
Spanish Wells Rentals
Spanish Wells is a unique and tightly-knit community on St. George's Cay off the northern tip of Eleuthera — one of the most prosperous fishing and residential communities in the Bahamas. Spanish Wells rental homes average approximately $3,000 per month, with three-bedroom homes available at the Leo Pinder Main Street address at $3,000 per month. Browse Spanish Wells real estate for purchase options.
Governors Harbour Rentals
Governors Harbour is Eleuthera's central community hub and the primary rental market on the island's mainland. Entry apartments in James Cistern start from approximately $1,800 per month. The Oceanview Triplex at Governors Harbour offers a commercial-scale rental opportunity. Governors Harbour combines the most established services and amenities on Eleuthera with access to the island's best beaches and the Sunset Marina Village marina dock and boat slips. Browse Governors Harbour real estate.
Eleuthera Rental Pricing at a Glance
| Area | Entry price | Upper range | Average |
|---|---|---|---|
| James Cistern / Governors Harbour | From $1,800/mo | $4,500/mo | ~$2,750/mo |
| Spanish Wells | From $3,000/mo | $3,000/mo | ~$3,000/mo |
| Russell Island | From $3,500/mo | $3,500/mo | ~$3,500/mo |
| Harbour Island | From $9,000/mo | $9,000/mo | ~$9,000/mo |
| Island-wide median | From $1,800/mo | $9,000/mo | ~$3,500/mo |
Frequently Asked Questions
How much does it cost to rent a home in Eleuthera Bahamas?
Eleuthera long-term rentals range from approximately $1,800 per month for entry apartments in James Cistern to $9,000 per month for Harbour Island premium rentals. The island-wide median is approximately $3,500 per month. Spanish Wells homes average $3,000 per month. Governors Harbour rentals average $2,750 per month. Contact Sheldon Pitt at (242) 544-7509 for current availability.
Explore Eleuthera Rentals and Real Estate
Bahamas homes for rent — island-wide rental hub.
Nassau long-term rentals — Nassau rental comparison.
Eleuthera real estate for sale — homes, land and properties across the island.
Harbour Island real estate for sale — pink sand beach homes and luxury residences.
Spanish Wells real estate — unique northern Eleuthera community.
Governors Harbour real estate — central Eleuthera hub.
Sunset Marina Village boat and dock slips — marina dockage in Governors Harbour.
Abaco homes for rent — Marsh Harbour, Treasure Cay and Elbow Cay.
Bimini homes for rent — rental homes at Bimini Bay Resort.
Grand Bahama Freeport homes for rent — rental comparison for Grand Bahama.
Sheldon Pitt — Eleuthera and Out Island specialist.
The data relating to real estate for sale/lease on this website comes in part from a cooperative data exchange program of the Bahamas Multiple Listing Service (MLS) in which these Brokers participate (BREA). The properties displayed may not be all of the properties in the Bahamas MLS database, or all of the properties listed with Brokers participating in the cooperative data exchange program. Properties listed by Brokers other than this Broker/Agent are marked with the IDX Symbol, indicating an agreement to exchange property information. Detailed information about such properties are noted as Courtesy of: The Bahamas MLS. Information provided is thought to be reliable but is not guaranteed to be accurate. You are advised to verify facts that are important to you. No warranties, expressed or implied, are provided for the data herein, or for their use or interpretation by the user. This information is protected from unlawful duplication by copyright.