Private Islands for Sale in Eleuthera & Harbour Island

For buyers seeking a private island here, the appeal is rare: total seclusion moments from one of the most coveted destinations in the region. Current opportunities include trophy estate islands with established residences, docks, and infrastructure. Explore the full inventory of Private islands for sale in The Bahamas. 

Why Buy a Private Island Near Eleuthera & Harbour Island

The North Eleuthera area offers a combination that is genuinely rare in the private island market: meaningful seclusion paired with real accessibility. Harbour Island, reached by a short boat ride from North Eleuthera, is one of the Caribbean's most sought-after destinations, known for its three-mile pink-sand beach, its boutique hotels, and a long-standing draw for discerning international visitors. The cays scattered through these waters allow an owner to enjoy that world while retaining complete privacy on their own island.

Accessibility is a defining advantage here. North Eleuthera International Airport supports both commercial and private aviation, including full-service FBO facilities, so a private island in this area can be reached far more easily than islands in the remote Out Islands, without sacrificing the sense of escape.

Featured: Crown Pigeon Island

The standout opportunity in this region is Crown Pigeon Island, an extraordinary 11-acre tropical estate island set in the calm, crystalline waters of North Eleuthera, just 1.6 miles from Harbour Island. The island sits only about 3 miles from North Eleuthera International Airport, allowing seamless arrivals by commercial or private aviation, including full-service FBO facilities.

Offered as a fully developed estate, Crown Pigeon Island combines absolute seclusion with turnkey infrastructure, including substantial residences and a dock, making it one of the most significant private island estates available in The Bahamas. For qualified buyers, it represents both a legacy asset and, given its value, a clear pathway to Bahamian residency by investment.

View the Crown Pigeon Private Island For Sale active listing. 

What to Know About Buying a Private Island Here

Buying a private island near Eleuthera and Harbour Island follows the same principles that apply across The Bahamas, with a few region-specific points worth understanding:

Title:

Most Bahamian private islands are sold freehold, conveying full ownership of the land. Confirm the title type for any specific island during due diligence.

Access and infrastructure

A key advantage of this region is proximity to North Eleuthera International Airport and Harbour Island services. Developed estate islands here may include existing residences, docks, water, power, and standby systems, while any undeveloped parcels would require infrastructure to be planned.

Costs

 Foreign buyers pay Value Added Tax of 10% on the conveyance, and real estate commission is paid by the seller. The Bahamas levies no income, capital gains, or inheritance tax.

Foreign ownership

Foreign nationals can own Bahamian private islands on a freehold basis. Certain acquisitions involve registration or permit requirements for non-Bahamians; confirm the current rules with a Bahamian attorney for your specific purchase.

Read our complete guide on How To Buy a Private Island in The Bahamas.

An Eleuthera Island Purchase Can Qualify You for Bahamas Residency

A real estate investment of $1,000,000 USD or more qualifies a foreign buyer to apply for Bahamian permanent residency, with accelerated consideration available at $1,500,000 or more. A private island estate in this region comfortably exceeds those thresholds, meaning your purchase can secure both an exceptional asset and a pathway to residency in a country with no income, capital gains, or inheritance tax. These conditions are administered by the Bahamas Department of Immigration and should be verified directly.

Why Work With Pitt Property Group

Private island transactions in the Eleuthera and Harbour Island area demand discretion, local knowledge, and an understanding of island title, access, and infrastructure.

Sheldon Pitt, Broker Owner of Pitt Property Group, has more than 30 years of experience in Bahamian real estate and is a recognized authority on Out Island and investment property, including private islands and cays. He personally represents the private islands in our portfolio and works one-on-one with buyers seeking informed, confidential representation, from first evaluation through to acquisition.

Explore Private Islands Across The Bahamas

All private islands for sale in The Bahamas

Exuma private islands for sale

Abaco private islands for sale

How to buy a private island in The Bahamas Guide

Frequently Asked Questions

Are there private islands for sale near Harbour Island, Bahamas?

Yes. The waters around North Eleuthera and Harbour Island include private islands, such as Crown Pigeon Island, an 11-acre estate island located about 1.6 miles from Harbour Island. Availability changes as inventory turns over; see the current listings above.

How do you get to a private island near Eleuthera?

The region is served by North Eleuthera International Airport, which supports commercial and private aviation including full-service FBO facilities. Private islands in the area are typically reached by a short boat transfer, making them notably more accessible than remote Out Island cays.

How much do private islands near Eleuthera and Harbour Island cost?

Pricing depends on size, development status, and proximity to Harbour Island. Developed trophy estate islands in this prestigious area are among the higher-value private islands in The Bahamas. See current listings for specific pricing.

Can a foreign national buy a private island in Eleuthera?

Yes. Foreign nationals can own Bahamian private islands on a freehold basis. Certain acquisitions involve registration or permit requirements for non-Bahamians, which should be confirmed with a Bahamian attorney for the specific property.

Does buying an island here qualify me for Bahamas residency?

A real estate investment of $1,000,000 USD or more qualifies a foreign buyer to apply for permanent residency, and island estates in this region exceed that threshold. Residency conditions are set by the Bahamas Department of Immigration and should be confirmed directly.